American Idiot is an All That sketch parodying American Idol, featuring Kyle Sullivan as Brian Peefest, Giovonnie Samuels as Mandy Snackson, Chelsea Brummet as Polly Baboon, and Jack as Slimon Bowel. Remaining cast-members would perform acts of idiocy on stage, and the judges would respond in the same manner as their real-life counterparts.

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.