- Spella (Chelsea Brummet) - A spoiled and stuck-up witch.
- Vlad (Jack DeSena) - A suave and wealthy vampire.
- Spirit (Lisa Foiles) - The ghost of a cheerleader who was murdered after having a barbecue fork stuck in her head.
- Frankie (Shane Lyons) - An idiotic monster that is based on Frankenstein's Monster.
- Farrah (Giovonnie Samuels) - A sassy mummy.
- Zoe (Jamie Lynn Spears) - A decaying zombie.
- Head (Christina Kirkman) - A frozen, disgruntled severed head found in the refrigerator.
- Gabe (Kyle Sullivan) - An accountant who turns into a werewolf.
This sketch was voted as the greatest in All That history in the 10th Anniversary Reunion Special.